Chicago has had an art fair for galleries for 45 years. Currently, Expo Chicago has the international reputation that is required for success. Now there is a new kid on the block trying to break into the scene by attracting the not so famous galleries and artists. The Chicago Art Fair opened with 56 exhibitors on October 7. When I visited the fair on October 9, there were few visitors, and there was no problem getting down the aisles or seeing the individual works in gallery booths. This was in sharp contrast to April’s Expo Chicago, which was constantly crowded. The location of this fair at The Mart (formerly the Merchandise Mart) did make it easier to get to, being directly connected to a rapid transit line. But, because of its low ceilings, exhibitors do not like this venue as much as Navy Pier (the location of Expo Chicago). Having been to both, I was not bothered by that architectural quirk.
What became apparent while walking through Chicago Art Fair was that not enough care was given to curating the participants’ offerings. None of the work was unprofessional, but much did not rise above what is commonly known as “decorator art.” That became a disadvantage for the galleries that showed more sophisticated work, drowning their selections in a sea of mediocrity.
Still, there were pieces that deserve recognition. A few works by historically famous artists made their way to the booths of this fair. Vallarino Fine Art showed a charming modest-sized Alexander Calder painting on paper. Untitled (1962) features a field of red and black splotches that drip down the paper and begin to cover three black plant forms, the center one resembling a flower. Another was a midsized Al Held, Untitled (2003) at the Lawrence Fine Art booth. Held’s piece shows an abstract depiction of the number 55 in bright, mostly primary, colors. Vallarino Fine Art also presented a remarkably benign and lyrical painting, Blue Flag and Gold Sky (1981), by Chicago native Roger Brown. The rather large painting contains Brown’s signature sky with balloon shaped clouds creating a descending ombre from almost black to gold. A row of cattails and blue irises populate the bottom two-thirds of the painting. In viewing Brown’s work for nearly 50 years, I have never seen a piece of his so idyllic—and so sure not to offend.
Following a Chicago theme, Gallery Victor showed three collages by Chicago’s once enfant terrible Wesley Kimler who made a splash in the post-impressionist days with huge, highly gestural abstract canvases (one measuring 15 x 27 feet). Today, his work is more subdued and smaller scaled. For example, Drawing Collage (2026) is a mere 53 x 47 inches. The composition is more refined than his earlier work, although hints of his wilder side peek out via the sharp, pointed edges.
The portraiture on display offered an interesting contrast in styles. Galleria Barbara Paci from Italy showed a selection of portraits by Agostino Rocco. The one that particularly caught my eye was Euriloco. In it, a handsome but somber looking young man with blue eyes, short-cropped hair, and dressed in a black shirt is sporting a white pearl necklace with a miniature plastic pig’s head pendant. Rocco’s virtuoso painting technique is highly traditional with roots as far back as the Renaissance. Angst over civilization’s present state is etched into the figure’s expression—or so it seemed to this viewer. The other portraits by Rocco had a similar feel.
In stark contrast, Aspen Art Gallery from Aspen, Colorado, showed several portraits by Alea Pinar Du Pre. These large acrylic works (60 x 40 inches) were highly stylized images of women that had a camp tone because of the exaggerated hair styles and expressions. On top of that, the models were dressed in neo-Mondrian garb overlaid with areas of diagonal hatching meant to act as shading. The backgrounds extend the Mondrian-like patterns to make the works look like stained glass windows. The result is that Bellatrix is reminiscent of Rue Paul with her enormous hair, and Serafina vaguely resembles Gretta Garbo—a sharp visual contrast to the prostitute by the same name in Fellini’s film 8 ½, although possibly representing the same profession. There is an old Drag saying, “too much is never enough,” but in these two paintings, too much is exactly that.
Gebhardt’s “portrait” Absconded uses a late-twentieth-century aesthetic style. At 69 ½ x 74 ½ inches, it is one of the larger paintings in the fair. It has a cadaverous tone with a that face suggests what one would expect a corpse to look like. This is reinforced by the fact that the piece is painted on a canvas cobbled together from half a dozen pieces of canvas. The facial structure resembles Frankenstein’s monster from horror movies. Yet, there is a strange attractiveness to it and there is a subtle subtext to the piece. The face’s right eye is in partial shadow and colored a dull, clotted blood red, while the left eye is mostly white with the suggestion of a cornea sketched in. One thinks of legends of good and evil, war and peace, Jekyll and Hyde. I found it one of the more compelling pieces in the fair.
A particularly engaging piece in the portrait category is Nathalia Edenmont’s A Moment Like This. Edenmont is famous for encompassing her models in enormously skirted dresses made of flowers or other plant material (once, even beetles). She then photographs the model using a large format Sinar camera with 8×10 film and markets the images as large C-prints in small editions. In a way, the work challenges Western notions of feminism. We are presented with a female figure enveloped in a garment with an impossibly large skirt, much like European eighteenth-century royal court attire. Yet as beautiful as she looks, the model is imprisoned in the garment that is supposed to proclaim her superior standing. However, there is another interpretation: she is a prisoner of her own nature inundated in flowers, the traditional symbol of femininity and fecundity. Unlike Du Pre’s female caricatures, this representation speaks of real cultural issues.
For the most engaging “portrait” of the show, I would have to pick Giant Tusker Approaches #1 by Graham Hobart, a nature photographer who creates large scale infrared photography focusing on African and American West wildlife. Hobart took this image in Amboseli National Park, Kenya, while an elderly elephant was calmly approaching him, as if to say hello. Hobart describes the encounter in these words: “This was my third time to visit this old elephant whose tusks were so large one nearly touched the ground when he walked. Because of Man’s insatiable lust for ivory, it is extremely rare to find an elephant that has reached this age.” He does justice to the image by presenting it in a 60 x 44 inch version.
Hovering between a serious exploration of a novel subject and decorator art, there was a series of barn paintings by Michael Gregory shown by Nancy Hoffman Gallery. A large portion of Gregory’s work seems to be about barns and the agricultural landscape. The barns, rendered meticulously realistic, acquire a sense drama in their solitude. Each piece in this quartet is named after locations in the Great Plains. They have a melancholy reminiscent of some of Andrew Wyeth’s work and some of the compulsiveness of Claude Monet’s haystacks. But their dogged, repetitive realism also hints at Bob Ross. As a group lined up on a wall, as they were shown at the fair, they made a commanding yet pretty picture.
Moving from rural to urban landscape, Enrique Santana also employs realism. Gallery Victor showed his large painting Streeterville. Anyone who has lived in Chicago for a time will recognize that the painting is not an image of a particular view. It is a composite of buildings found along and north of the Chicago River—a collection of Chicago skyscrapers, not all of them famous or even noteworthy and not in their real location with respect to one another. Santana paints a composite reality—a hard-edged impression of this urban landscape. What stands out is the persistent architectonic grid that permeates the composition and binds all the buildings together, from those that are 100 years old to those built in this century. Santana and Gregory both try to capture the mood of a particular environment, but in different ways: Gregory shows us a list; Santana shows us a bouquet.
There were a number of works that fell into the category of “Things you would have seen at SOFA. (SOFA was an acronym for Sculpture Objects Functional Art and Design that existed from 1995 to 2019). For example, a pair of trompe l’oeil untitled C-prints by Bas Meeuws at Echo Fine Arts were of fanciful flower arrangements digitally assembled and manipulated to emulate Dutch and Flemish still-life paintings from the seventeenth century. Made from images of real plants and objects, they look impossibly real. They would provide a stunningly pretty arrangement over your sofa—if you can afford them.
The most interesting glass piece I saw was Stephen Rolph Powell’s large “vase” titled Hypnotic Shrug Smith shown by Trifecta Glass Art Lounge from Lexington, Kentucky. Powell, a renowned glass blower, has fashioned many these forms using the murrine method where molten colored glass is layered around a central core and then blow it into a desired shape. Powell’s piece is not only strikingly beautiful to look at, but it has a subtle sexual undertone due to its shape. (It made this viewer chuckle upon first viewing.) After reviewing dozens of these fairs, I have never seen a glass piece with such an original form and use of color. Powell’s work is truly unique.
Robert Bristow’s Untitled Totem brought a different kind of response. The work first made me think how different it was from Thaddeus Mosley’ wood sculpture (which we wrote about a few months ago on the event of his passing.) Mosley’s sculptures are precariously balanced, untreated, large pieces of wood, evoking a primeval power. Bristow’s exhibit refined woodworking most often seen in fine furniture. But there is a catch: as much as it suggests one, Untitled Totem is not a cabinet. Bristow imbues a Magritte-like, surreal tenor to the work that makes it interesting.
Finally, there was one piece of “high tech” art in the show, Anthony James’s 80” Triacontahedron (Solar White). This large work made of specialized glass and LEDs had a science fiction feel to it. The complex geometry of the structure was intriguing, especially to a mathematically inclined viewer. This kind of large work using novel lighting techniques has appeared from time to time at Expo Chicago, always in a solitary corner, as was the case for this piece.
The Chicago art Fair was an attempt to get a second fair going in Chicago that could attract collectors with more modest means. (I do not recall seeing any works offered for seven figures or even six figures, as happen regularly at Expo Chicago, but five-figure prices were common.) Walk-in traffic at galleries has declined in recent years, and the industry is trying to get their products to more potential customers through fairs (online sales are limited due to the inability for the buyer to see the actual work). Viewer attendance at this fair, while I was there for an entire afternoon, was dismally small. This attempt at yet another fair was unable to attract enough high-quality work to ensure its survival, despite “official” reports of brisk sales. There were, however, a baker’s dozen of pieces in the Chicago Art Fair that this viewer found rose above the mediocrity of the rest. Overall, there are too many high-end fairs across the country competing for collector and gallery attention and participation fees to make and a second fair in Chicago a feasible proposition.
Michel Ségard is the Editor in Chief of the New Art Examiner and a former adjunct assistant professor at the School of the Art Institute of Chicago. He has been a published art critic for more than 45 years and is also the author of numerous exhibition catalog essays.
SUBSCRIBE
Receive email notifications when new articles are posted and learn more about our paid subscription
Please provide your name and email: